“But What Would People Think?!”

Two young men, one light skinned and one dark skinned, look mockingly at a crying dark skinned woman on a street. All are dressed casually.
Photo by Keira Burton from Pexels

“But what would people THINK?!”  That familiar internal shriek cuts through our thoughts, building a cage around our choices.

Humans are social animals.  Once upon a time in our evolution, fitting into the group was literally a matter of life and death.  Unfortunately for us, our society has changed much faster than our brains can keep up.

When we lived in small hunter-gatherer groups, it was vitally important for our survival that we remain part of them.  The dangers that faced us then were quick and immediate.  Being attacked by a predator that a fellow human could save us from, fights over resources, an injury that left us helpless.  In our lives today, our stresses are more chronic.  Ongoing work deadlines, bills, keeping up with responsibilities to family, bosses, colleagues and friends.

Our brains are ‘threat-detection machines’ in Paul Gilbert’s Compassion Focused Model, but they are best at detecting threats which appear and are then over quickly.  Now we live with constant stress, our brains don’t know what to do with it – so they fall back on what they know, which is that everything is immediate and a life or death issue.  I think this has got much harder with the invention of the internet and social media, which opens us up to more potential of public shaming than any generations before would ever have experienced.

To try to protect us, our brains have evolved a number of ‘shortcuts’ – quick ways to process a situation to maximise our chances of surviving whatever is going on.  The standard CBT model calls these “cognitive distortions”, but I’m not really a fan of that model because I think it can leave the person who is suffering feeling blamed for ‘thinking wrong’ rather than tackling anything.  What we need to grow and learn is compassion and help, not blame and shame.  So I much prefer to call these shortcuts “Unhelpful Thinking Habits” (you can find a sheet of examples here) and think of them a bit differently.  All of us have these habits, all of us to a greater or lesser degree, so you will recognise them in yourself!  You are battling many many thousands of years of evolution here.  Give yourself a break.

Much like wisdom teeth or your appendix, once upon a time in human evolution they were useful.  Now they can cause more problems than they solve.  The good news is we can spot what is going on and do something about it.  The bad news is it’s not a quick surgery – we have to challenge ourselves and build new habits so they don’t come back.

The Unhelpful Thinking Habit that is particularly relevant to this blog is “Mind Reading”, when we assume we know what other people are thinking – usually about us, and often negative.  It can be a particularly tricky one to tackle, because some amount of social approval is necessary for us to get the things we want.  Paul Simon may have sung, “I am a rock, I am an island” but really no-one is!  The problem arises when we believe we know exactly what other people want and expect, and then live according to that, but without ever checking the facts.

Many of our beliefs about what other people will think of us come from childhood.  You might have had a disapproving authority figure such as a parent or teacher.  We do learn vital lessons about how to be a person in our culture from these authority figures.  However, at that age we swallow whole what they say and don’t realise that they may not be completely right.  Or that what was appropriate and helpful then isn’t now we are adults.  We might have been bullied by peers at school or in work, or by a boss, backing up those beliefs.  We get stuck thinking that if we act like everybody wants, we will get the approval we crave and everything will be perfect.

The trouble is, we assume we know what everyone wants.  Maybe we do know, maybe we don’t.  Acting the way we think others want us to costs us something, often it costs us a lot.  We don’t think about that though – we just hear the shriek, “What would people think?!”.

So I ask you to consider – what would people think?  Why do you believe that, who told you they would think that?  Is it coming from them or from you?  What does their opinion mean to you, materially?  What are the consequences of them thinking that of you?  Can you live with those consequences?  Why or why not?

These are hard questions, but that’s the way we tackle Unhelpful Thinking Habits.  We run on automatic a lot, so stopping to pull the pieces apart and examine them can be difficult and painful.  If you are struggling with this issue, please feel free to contact me for an appointment.