Silencing the Inner Critic

Emma Thompson a counsellor, wearing glasses, a grey coat and a headscarf patterned with Van Gogh’s “Irises” stands in front of a print of the same painting - this depicts iris blooms in purples and greens with a yellow background.  The image is presented as a polaroid photo on a blue background, with the words “Silencing the Inner Critic” and “Opis Counselling” beneath.What links Vincent Van Gogh, Star Trek and the Inner Critic?  Well, just me in this blog really.  I’ll also admit it’s tenuous, but I hope to give food for thought!

I was lucky enough to be able to visit the Immersive Van Gogh exhibit in London during my annual leave last week.  I was struck by one of the quotations from Van Gogh, “If you hear a voice within you say ‘you cannot paint,’ then by all means paint, and that voice will be silenced.”  That linked up in my mind with a quotation from the previous week’s episode of Lower Decks (S2E7, “Where Pleasant Fountains Lie”).  Ensign Tendi tells her friend and colleague Ensign Rutherford that he needs to get out of his comfort zone to advance his career.  Rutherford responds by declaring, “But I love my zone!  It’s so comfortable!”

The trouble is, a comfort zone can actually be anything but comfortable.  We can find ourselves being hemmed in and restricted.  We can believe that going beyond it is too frightening or too difficult for us, so we stay where we are.  Frighteningly, the more we stay in our comfort zone, the smaller it becomes!

So thinking about Rutherford, and seeing that Van Gogh quote, made me think about the beliefs we hold and the stories we tell about ourselves.  I have written about creativity before, and the beliefs and messages from our Inner Critic which might hold us back, here, here and here.

It’s not just about wanting to be good at painting or dancing or singing or any other artistic or creative endeavour.  The beliefs we hold about what it means to be able to do something, and whether or not we can, are able to impact every aspect of our lives.  You might tell yourself that you are not capable of doing a particular job or join a particular career.  Or that you aren’t pretty/slim/young enough to wear the clothes you really want to.  You might doubt your ability to be a good parent.  You might turn down educational or career opportunities because you immediately reject the idea you have the ability to do them, even though getting the offer in the first place means someone sees something in you that says you can.  You might even move beyond doubting just your abilities and end up doubting your very self, declaring that you are just not the kind of person who is able to do these exciting things.

When challenged on this, you might defend yourself further by saying, “well, I am just being realistic”.  I want to question what that word means.  Is your assessment of how “realistic” something is based on a fact or a thought?  What has led you to believe you are unable to do these things?  Did it come from an authority figure early in life?  Have you had a bad experience when you tried something?  Have other people’s opinions about you got into your head to the point where they have become your own?  Who are the ‘kind of people’ who do these exciting things you want to do, and why not you?

We all have an Inner Critic.  The Inner Critic seeks to keep us where we are not because it hates us but because it is scared.  It wants to keep us safe.  Putting yourself out there, trying new things, is never without risk.  Risk is scary.  The Inner Critic is frightened.  It says harsh things that keep you in a safe comfort zone that is also boring and restrictive.  The compassion focused approach encourages us to thank that Inner Critic for its protection, to give it a warm hug and say we see its fear but it’s okay, we’ve got this.  There are some good suggestions for how to diminish the power of your Inner Critic here.

What might you do, if you could thank your Inner Critic for it’s concern but go and do The Thing anyway?